Mobile Technology in Classrooms: BBC Radio Scotland
By Dan Sodergren
As a fervent advocate for technological advancement and anenthusiast who regularly discusses the future of work across various media platforms, the recent proposal to ban mobile phones in Scottish schools sparked my interest and created an intriguing discussion on the airwaves. This development has catapulted the role of technology in education into the spotlight once again.
A Call to the Future
In the past, we championed the integration of computers intoclassrooms. Now, mobile phones—pocket-sized computers in their own right—offer similar, if not greater, educational possibilities. These devices could compensate for slow school internet connectivity and outdated tech, as well as
enhance collaborative learning through various apps, thereby transforming into formidable educational partners. But do the potential benefits outweigh the downfalls of trying to monitor mobile phone usage in schools, especially in schools where budgets are tight?
It is important to recognise that today's youth will shapethe workplace of the future, a landscape infused with AI and ongoing digital progress. An outright ban on mobile phones may overlook the essential digital fluency needed for them to succeed, but in the current educational climate,
there may be no other option.
The Ethical Use of Technology
Technology's effectiveness is determined by how it isharnessed, and how it is harnessed depends largely on budgets and the rules and discipline within the school. Responsible use of mobile phones, I believe, can revolutionise learning, but I understand the issues with their implementation.
My book, "Intelligence: The Fifth IndustrialRevolution," highlights emotional intelligence as acornerstone in shaping our future. I think it is important to consider the deep emotional ties students have with their devices—a connection solidified during the pandemic's isolation, as phones became their portals to education and social interaction. This connection could be powerful to harness during their education. On the other hand, it may exacerbate mobile phone addiction and a
ban might provide important time away from devices.
The Journey Through Adolescence: Should we Adopt aTailored Tech Approach?
Given the significant developmental and cognitivedifferences between younger children and teenagers, it's possible that mobile phone policies in schools should be flexible and evolve alongside the educational journey of a student. This perspective acknowledges the reality that what is appropriate for a 12-year-old may not be for a 16-year-old, echoing the sensibility we apply to content ratings in film and television.
However, as highlighted during the discussion on BBC ScotlandRadio, there is resistance to such a nuanced approach as it would bring even more complexity to the already complex job of educating children and teenagers. As a parent and a long-time education sector participant, I acknowledge the
disruptive impact mobile phones can have—Scottish secondary schools report a 92% disruption rate in classes due to mobile devices.
Striking a Balance
In this era of digital transformation, our collective goalshould be to empower our youth with the knowledge and skills to not just navigate but also positively leverage the digital world, enhancing their personal and communal lives. I would love to see a world in which educators are given the resources and support to be able to utilise the multitude advantages of using mobiles in the classroom, but until they are funded properly, I fear such a policy will just not be worth the time or the budget.
References: